Made with love and nicotine in San Francisco

Dialers for Medicare agencies, compared: What to evaluate and who does it well

The best dialer for a Medicare agency depends on how the agency sells. Teams working large purchased-lead lists need pacing and caller ID protection built for volume. Inbound and book-driven agencies need routing, recording, and a clean record of every member.

The short answer

It depends on how your agency sells. Convoso, AgentTech and Five9 also sell AI agents alongside their dialers.

  • Large outbound teams on purchased leadsConvoso or VICIdial
  • Inbound-heavy teams staffed by peopleFive9
  • A dialer with a CRM built inReadyMode, AgentTech or TLD CRM
  • Dialing inside policy managementEnrollHere
  • AI employees working every lead and every membercareCycle

What should you evaluate in a Medicare dialer?

Nine things, roughly in the order they cost you money when they're wrong. Each ends with the question to put to every vendor.

  1. 1

    Who takes the first minute

    Ask “Of an agent's hour, how many minutes are spent with a qualified prospect?”

    Why it matters

    Most of a dialing hour goes to no-answers, voicemails, and prospects who don't qualify. A dialer can put your agents on those calls, or AI can screen first and transfer only qualified prospects. Answering-machine detection, transcription, QA scoring, live coaching, and AI that dials and screens on its own are different products.

  2. 2

    Cost at AEP volume

    Ask “What does it cost to add ten agents for October, and to drop them in January?”

    Why it matters

    Per-seat price, annual or monthly billing, seat minimums, carrier minutes, and onboarding fees.

  3. 3

    Dialing modes and pacing

    Ask “Can each campaign set its own pace?”

    Why it matters

    Preview, power, progressive, and predictive, paced per campaign. Fast predictive pacing suits large aged-lead lists; slower modes suit calls to your own members.

  4. 4

    Inbound and routing

    Ask “What happens to a call at 8 p.m. on a Saturday in AEP?”

    Why it matters

    Queues, callbacks, after-hours handling, and routing by state license and carrier appointments, so no call lands with someone who can't help.

  5. 5

    Caller ID reputation

    Ask “What happens when a number gets flagged as spam?”

    Why it matters

    Number rotation, spam-label remediation, per-number call limits, and branded caller ID. Without them, answer rates fall fast.

  6. 6

    Compliance

    Ask “Where do recordings live, and for how long?”

    Why it matters

    Calling hours by the member's time zone, DNC scrubbing, consent records, and opt-outs honored across channels. Plus full recording of marketing and sales calls, which CMS requires keeping for at least six years from October 1, 2026.

  7. 7

    Data

    Ask “Can you show cost per acquisition by lead vendor without a spreadsheet?”

    Why it matters

    Dispositions, recordings, and lead source on the client's record automatically.

  8. 8

    The calls after the sale

    Ask “Who makes the welcome and check-in calls, and does the dialer know which members are due one?”

    Why it matters

    A sale is revenue only once the policy effectuates and the member stays.

  9. 9

    Support and setup

    Ask “Who do I call on the first Monday of AEP?”

    Why it matters

    Who builds your campaigns, how fast changes happen, and who answers during AEP.

Medicare dialers at a glance

ConvosoBest for: Large outbound teams on purchased and aged leadsPricing: By quote, per seat, mostly annual plans
ReadyModeBest for: Growing agencies that want a dialer and CRM togetherPricing: $199 or $249 a license a month billed annually upfront; $239 or $299 billed monthly
TLD CRMBest for: Health and Medicare call centers of 15 or more seatsPricing: $100 a seat a month plus minutes, 15-seat minimum, $1,000 setup fee
EnrollHereBest for: Agencies and FMOs of about 25 or more agents that want policy management tooPricing: From $5,000 a month for 25 users
VICIdialBest for: Large operations with their own telephony staffPricing: Free software; you pay for hosting, minutes and support
CallToolsBest for: Outbound teams that want to start dialing fastPricing: By quote
Five9Best for: Centers of 50 or more seats running service and sales togetherPricing: From $159 per concurrent user a month, 50-seat minimum; usage charges may apply
AgentTechBest for: Cost-conscious call centers that want coaching and QA on every callPricing: $50 a seat a month plus usage
careCycleBest for: Medicare and ACA agencies that want AI employees to dial and screenPricing: Per active policy plus usage, no per-seat charge

The dialers Medicare agencies use

Convoso

High-volume outbound.

Fits larger outbound teams working purchased and aged leads.

Pricing and details

Insurance call centers running large Medicare and final expense campaigns favor it for caller ID reputation management and scripting. Ignite scores outbound numbers and rotates them to protect answer rates. Predictive, power, progressive, and preview dialing are built in, with DNC scrubbing, attempt limits, and state calling-rule controls. Convoso Voice AI Agent, built on its Voso.ai technology, qualifies outbound leads and handles inbound calls. It transfers sales-ready prospects to human agents in Convoso's platform.

Pricing

By quote, based on seats, features, and services, mostly on annual plans, with carrier fees billed separately. An insurance lead vendor reports about $100 to $200 a seat, a third-party estimate, not a published price. The pricing page states no seat minimum, so confirm one in the quote.

ReadyMode

A predictive dialer and built-in CRM in one, with a solutions page for healthcare and Medicare insurance.

Fits growing agencies that want predictable per-seat cost and a built-in CRM.

Pricing and details

Pricing

Published per license: $199 (Starter) or $249 (iQ) a month billed annually and paid upfront, or $239 and $299 billed monthly. Outbound minutes are included under a fair-use policy, and inbound minutes are $0.02. Some voicemail-drop usage is charged separately.

TLD CRM (TLDialer)

A CRM and VoIP dialer built for health and life insurance call centers, refined over more than ten years with hundreds of call centers.

Fits health and Medicare call centers of 15 or more seats that want the dialer and the CRM from one insurance-native vendor.

Pricing and details

It has insurance-specific dispositions and lead flow, an API, and TLIntel AI call QA.

Pricing

Published: $100 a seat a month plus $0.02 a minute on the Agency plan, with a 15-seat minimum and a $1,000 one-time setup fee. Numbers are $1 each, and texts are $0.03 out and $0.02 in.

EnrollHere (Integrates with careCycle)

A Medicare, ACA, and final expense dialer inside a policy management platform.

Fits Medicare agencies and FMOs of roughly 25 or more agents that want dialing and policy management in one platform.

Pricing and details

Connect handles calls with ratio dialing (controlled power dialing), routing by skill and license, real-time controls, recording, transcription, and audit-ready records. Flow adds call tracking and attribution. The wider EnrollHere Complete platform adds policy management, hierarchies, commissions, and complaint handling.

Pricing

Published in monthly platform tiers with included usage allowances. Complete starts at $7,500 a month for up to 25 users and runs to $50,000 a month for up to 500. The Connect telephony suite alone starts at $5,000 a month at the 25-user tier.

VICIdial

Control and cost at scale.

Fits larger operations and BPOs with in-house staff who own telephony and compliance.

Pricing and details

It is open source with no license fee. It covers inbound, blended, manual, preview, progressive, and predictive calling, with configurable pacing and answering-machine detection. A documented DNC.com integration handles DNC scrubbing.

Pricing

Free software. Budget separately for servers, carrier minutes, support, and administration. A VICIdial hosting vendor puts that all-in cost at about $60 to $130 a seat a month. The same vendor puts managed hosting from about $75 to $90 a seat.

CallTools

Getting an outbound team dialing fast.

Fits outbound teams that want a quick start, using its built-in CRM or one of the 20+ CRMs it connects to.

Pricing and details

It has predictive, power, preview, and progressive dialing, and CallTools says most teams are running within 24 hours. A built-in CRM with SMS and email is included.

Pricing

By quote.

Five9

Enterprise blended inbound and outbound, with predictive, power, progressive, and preview dialing.

Fits 50+ seat centers that run service and sales together.

Pricing and details

It adds IVR, real-time agent assist, workforce management on its higher bundles, and AI agents for self-service. In our view, pricing per concurrent user suits centers that staff up and down around seasonal peaks like AEP.

Pricing

Published per concurrent user a month, with a 50-seat minimum. Core, which covers all channels including voice, is $159. The $119 Digital plan covers digital channels only. Usage charges may apply, and higher tiers are by quote.

AgentTech

An insurance dialer and CRM in one, at a low flat seat price, with AI for human agents.

Fits cost-conscious insurance call centers that want coaching and QA on every call.

Pricing and details

That means an in-call AI sales coach, compliance scoring on every recorded call, five dialing modes, and state-license routing. Optional AI voice agents answer calls, qualify leads, and warm-transfer them to agents.

Pricing

Published: $50 a seat a month with the CRM included and no setup fee or contract. VoIP at $0.025 a minute and AI usage, drawn from a prepaid wallet, are billed separately.

careCycle

The whole agency in one system: a predictive dialer, the member record, and AI employees that work every lead and every member.

Fits Medicare and ACA agencies of every size, call centers first, that want AI employees working every lead and every member while licensed agents sell.

Pricing and details

It has a predictive dialer and agent softphone, inbound routing and queues, branded caller ID, spam remediation and number rotation, and SMS and RCS. Every call is recorded, transcribed, and summarized (careCycle). AI employees work outbound lists and answer inbound calls, screening for intent and eligibility. They transfer qualified prospects to an available licensed agent with the record open. Every number has a daily limit, and calling pauses rather than burning a fresh number.

Pricing

Priced per active policy, so you pay for the members on your book, plus usage for calls and texts. There is no per-seat charge and every feature is included; agencies sign up and see their own plan in minutes.

Which dialer fits your operation?

Three things decide it more than seat count: where your calls come from, who takes the first minute, and where the call ends up. Start with the operation below that drives most of your revenue.

You dial purchased and aged leads with licensed agents

This is the classic predictive dialer job, priced per seat. Much of each agent's hour goes to no-answers, voicemails, and prospects who don't qualify. Convoso, ReadyMode, VICIdial, CallTools, and TLD CRM are built for it.

The other way is to let AI work the list, so only qualified, interested prospects reach a licensed agent who's free. careCycle works this way, with the member record in the same system. Convoso and AgentTech also sell AI agents that qualify and transfer.

Either way, compare cost per acquisition by lead source, not seat price.

Most of your calls are inbound

PPC, TV, and vendor transfers through Ringba or Retreaver. Every call needs answering, screening fast, and routing to an agent licensed in the caller's state, evenings and weekends included.

Five9 and EnrollHere route inbound calls to agents by skill, license, and availability, and Five9 also sells AI agents for self-service. On careCycle, Cora answers every inbound call or only the ones your agents can't get to, as you choose, around the clock. Ping-post checks that an agent is free before careCycle accepts a vendor transfer.

Your growth depends on the book you already have

Then the calls after the sale matter more than the dialer: welcome calls, check-ins, plan-change outreach before AEP, and cross-sell. A dialer alone doesn't make those calls. This is where careCycle's AI employees do most of their work.

You run a downline or several agencies

Hierarchy, commissions, and consistent reporting across agencies matter as much as dialing. EnrollHere pairs its dialer with policy management and commissions. Five9 suits a central contact center serving many agencies.

You're a solo agent or a team under five

A simple power dialer inside your CRM is enough. The Medicare CRM comparison covers bundles like Ringy and Agent CRM.

How careCycle is different

careCycle is the agency operating system with AI employees built in. They call every new lead instantly, qualify it, and transfer or book it. Then they welcome, serve and retain every member you write, so your licensed agents spend their hours selling.

Who works the listA typical dialerYour agents, with AI agents as an add-on from some vendorscareCycleAI employees call every new lead instantly, qualify it, and transfer or book it
What you pay forA typical dialerSeats, plus minutescareCycleActive policies, plus usage, with no per-seat charge
Adding agents for AEPA typical dialerMore seats to pay forcareCycleNo added seat cost
The member recordA typical dialerA separate CRM, unless one is bundledcareCycleThe dialer and the record in one system
Calls after the saleA typical dialerUp to your teamcareCycleAI employees make the welcome, check-in, plan-change and cross-sell calls
What you can seeA typical dialerCalls, talk time and dispositionscareCycleCPL, CPA and close rate by lead source, and every member reached

1,174

Appointments booked by the AI employee

4.8 million

AI calls, 3 AEPs and counting

1.1 million

Beneficiaries managed on careCycle

“AI is another person on your team. We have three agents, and we have the careCycle AI. Those are the four agents on our team. The more any one of them can do, the more leverage we get.”
Nikhail Singh, General Manager, GetScale Medicare Agency. Read the GetScale story

When another dialer fits better: If you sell several lines of insurance from one dialer, Convoso or Five9 covers more ground, and so does a multi-line insurance dialer like AgentTech.

More on how the careCycle dialer works, how careCycle works every lead, and how careCycle runs the call floor.

Switching dialers, or running two

A few things decide how a move goes:

  • Timing. Avoid switching between October 1 and December 7. Retraining a team mid-AEP costs more than any seat savings.
  • Your contract. Seat minimums and term length often decide when a move makes sense, so check them before you compare prices.
  • Prove it on one source first. Run one lead source or one campaign through the new setup. Compare cost per acquisition and close rate with your current dialer before moving everything.
  • EnrollHere agencies. EnrollHere runs dialing and policy management; sales flow into careCycle for the work after the sale, and status updates flow back.
  • Call tracking stays. Ringba or Retreaver keep routing; careCycle receives transfers through ping-post.

Everything that connects, and how, is in careCycle integrations.

FAQ

It depends on where your calls come from. Licensed agents dialing large purchased-lead lists: Convoso, VICIdial, or ReadyMode. Inbound-heavy operations staffed by people: Five9. Dialing and policy management in one platform: EnrollHere. AI that dials, screens, and transfers to available agents, with the member record in the same system: careCycle.

Yes for large purchased and aged-lead lists, where predictive pacing gets the most contacts per hour. For calls to your own members, slower, personal outreach fits better. The bigger question is who's on the line when someone answers: a licensed agent, or AI that screens first and transfers only qualified prospects.

Published prices: AgentTech, $50 a seat a month plus usage. TLD, $100 a seat a month plus $0.02 a minute, with a 15-seat minimum and a $1,000 setup fee. ReadyMode, $199 to $249 a license a month billed annually, or $239 to $299 billed monthly. Five9 Core, $159 a concurrent seat a month with a 50-seat minimum. EnrollHere Complete, from $7,500 a month for up to 25 users. Convoso and CallTools price by quote, and carrier minutes or other usage are extra on most.

At least six years, under CMS's CY2027 final rule, which applies from October 1, 2026. Marketing and sales calls must be recorded in full. Keep audio for years one through three, then audio or a complete and accurate transcript for years four through six. Enrollment records stay on the longer ten-year path. Recordings made before October 1, 2026 fell under the older ten-year expectation, which is why many agents and vendor blogs still quote ten years. Check what your carrier contracts require before deleting anything.

For dialing and screening, increasingly yes. Selling stays with licensed agents, so you still need them, just fewer of them grinding through dials.

Yes. AI can work an aged list no human team would spend hours on. It screens for interest and eligibility and transfers the qualified ones to a licensed agent. Consent rules still apply: AI voices count as artificial under the TCPA, so AI-voice telemarketing calls need prior express written consent. Check that the consent on aged leads covers AI voices before you dial, and remember CMS doesn't allow unsolicited marketing calls.

Staff a night shift, use an answering service, or put AI on the line. AI can answer and screen every after-hours call, then book a morning callback with a licensed agent or transfer live if one is on. Leads that wait until morning often go to whoever answered first.

They can, if they're set up for volume alone. One agent on Insurance Forums points out that Medicare prospects associate automated calls with scams, and that calling a list harder raises irritation. The safeguards match human dialing: limit attempts per lead and calls per number, and say who's calling and why. Transfer to a licensed agent quickly when someone is interested, and stop the moment they opt out.

Carriers' analytics providers score numbers on call volume, short calls, and how people react. Heavy dialing, triple-dialing the same lead, and using one number for everything all raise flags. One agent on Insurance Forums described spreading attempts out instead of triple-dialing to cut down on spam flags. The fixes that hold: register your numbers with the carriers' analytics providers, brand your caller ID, and cap daily calls per number. Keep separate numbers for prospecting and for clients, and remediate a flagged number rather than burning through fresh ones.

Screen before the transfer reaches a licensed agent. One agent taking live transfers described about one in three callers without Parts A and B. Others were drawn in by ads promising a "$3,000 stimulus check". Confirm eligibility, Medicare parts, Medicaid status, and real interest in the first minute, and accept vendor transfers only when an agent is free. Require consent records and recordings from every vendor, and track close rate and cost per acquisition by source to cut the ones that don't qualify.

No. careCycle helps agencies run the leads they already buy, alongside the lead vendors and call tracking they already use. Every source gets its own tracking number, so cost per lead, cost per acquisition, and close rate show up by vendor. Leads route to the right licensed agent, Cora answers every inbound call or only the ones your agents can't get to, day or night, and ping-post accepts vendor transfers only when an agent is free.

Sources

Start compounding your book.

Set up your agency

Running 50+ agents? Talk to us

Written by Vladimir Taikov, Head of Growth. Last checked .