Made with love and nicotine in San Francisco

The Medicare agency software guide: Every category, compared

Medicare agency software comes in about six categories. This guide compares each one: what to look for, who does it well, and which fits which kind of agency.

We make careCycle. When the right answer is someone else's software, we say so.

Follow one member through an agency.

Pick a step to compare the software that runs it.

  1. Step 1

    A lead comes in

    From a lead vendor, an ad, or a referral.

    Lead vendors and call tracking
  2. Step 2

    Someone calls

    An agent or an AI calls them back, fast.

  3. Step 3

    The record

    Their details, policy, and every call in one place.

  4. Step 4

    They enroll

    Quote and enroll, often through your FMO.

    Quoting and enrollment tools
  5. Step 5

    The year after

    Welcome calls, plan questions, renewals, and new sales.

  6. Step 6

    Everything in sync

    Every system shows the same member, with nothing typed in twice.

Start with how your agency runs

Three questions about your own operation shape almost every software decision:

  1. 1

    Where your revenue comes from

    Bought leads, inbound calls, your existing book, or a downline of agencies.

  2. 2

    Who works the phones

    Licensed agents on every call, or AI employees on screening, service, and outreach, with agents on the licensed conversations.

  3. 3

    Where the record lives

    The one system that holds the member, the policy, the writing agent, and every call, and that everything else syncs to.

Then start with the operation below that drives most of your revenue.

Outbound on purchased and aged leads

Dialer seats and agent hours on prospects who never qualify cost the most, so decide who takes the first minute of each call. Read the dialer guide and the voice AI guide.

Inbound from ads and vendor transfers

Every missed or misrouted call is a paid lead lost. You need fast screening, routing to an agent licensed in the caller's state, and after-hours coverage. Read the dialer guide, the voice AI guide, and the integrations guide for call tracking.

Growth from the book you already have

Effectuation, retention, and cross-sell move your numbers more than another lead source. Read the voice AI guide, the staffing guide, and the CRM guide.

A downline or several agencies

Hierarchy, commissions, and consistent reporting across agencies matter as much as any single tool. Read the CRM guide, the dialer guide, and the FMO section below.

A solo agent or a small team

One CRM with a built-in dialer usually covers it. Start with the CRM guide.

The numbers to bring to every vendor call

A vendor who can't talk about your operation in these numbers is selling features, not outcomes.

    • Cost per acquisition and close rate, by lead source
    • Effectuation rate, and retention at 120 days and 12 months
    • Licensed agents on staff in October versus January
    • How many members get a call after the sale, and how many also carry an ancillary policy like dental, vision, or hospital indemnity
    • What you pay today per seat, per minute, and per lead

How the categories connect

One member touches every category:

  1. 1

    The lead arrives

    From a vendor, a call-tracking line, or a referral. Ringba, Retreaver, and TrustedForm live here. Track each source separately to see what it costs you per sale.

  2. 2

    Someone calls or answers

    The dialer and phone system, with a licensed agent or AI on the first minute.

  3. 3

    The client and policy get a home

    The CRM or policy management system.

  4. 4

    The plan is quoted and the application submitted

    In a quoting and enrollment platform, often from your FMO. Intake tools like RetireFlo collect the Scope of Appointment, drugs, and doctors before the appointment.

  5. 5

    The year after the sale

    Welcome calls, questions, renewals, and cross-sell, handled by people, voice AI, or both.

  6. 6

    Everything stays connected

    integrations move the book between systems, so nobody types it in twice.

If you're contracted through an FMO

Check what your FMO or upline already gives you before you buy. Many include quoting and enrollment, a CRM, compliance tools, and back-office support with your contract, sometimes at no software cost.

Integrity

IntegrityCONNECT (formerly MedicareCENTER) for CRM, quoting, enrollment, SOAs, and call recording, plus IntegrityCONNECT Leads and Ask Integrity. Integrity says IntegrityCONNECT is free for Integrity agents and agencies.

Spark

A platform and back office with quote and enroll through SunFire and book-of-business management.

Others

Most large FMOs give their agents a quoting platform, either their own or one such as SunFire or ConnectureDRX PlanCompare.

Ask your upline what comes with the contract, who owns its data, and what happens to your book and its history if you move. Then fill the gaps with tools you choose. Spark agencies can read how careCycle supports Spark agencies.

Several FMOs offer careCycle accounts directly for their agencies. Ask your upline about careCycle, or send them this email to start the conversation.

How careCycle is different

careCycle is the agency operating system for Medicare and ACA: the dialer, the CRM and Medicare voice AI in one system, with AI employees working every lead and every member. Built first for call centers and telephonic agencies.

Dialer, CRM and voice AISeparate toolsThree products, connected by integrationscareCycleOne system and one member record
Who works the recordSeparate toolsYour agentscareCycleAI employees and your agents, side by side
What you pay forSeparate toolsUsually seats, per productcareCycleActive policies, plus usage, with no per-seat charge
Your book and dataSeparate toolsHeld in each vendor's systemcareCycleOwned by your agency, whatever you connect

300%

First-year ROI on careCycle

4.8 million

AI calls, 3 AEPs and counting

1.1 million

Beneficiaries managed on careCycle

“Now we've managed to push our accretion into the eighties, a lot of it due to the servicing and the feedback.”
Nikhail Singh, General Manager, GetScale Medicare Agency. Read the GetScale story

Works with careCycle: HealthSherpa · ConnectureDRX PlanCompare · Spark · MedicarePRO · GoGuruX · EnrollHere · AgencyBloc · Salesforce · GoHighLevel · Google and Outlook calendars · a REST API with sync endpoints and webhooks.

More on how careCycle works, start to finish and how careCycle is priced.

How we wrote these

  • Every vendor fact links to the vendor's own page, or to a named third party when the vendor doesn't publish it.
  • Prices are what vendors publish or what reviewers report, labeled that way. Vendors change prices, so check before you buy.
  • No rankings. Each guide matches tools to the kind of agency they fit.
  • Partners are labeled, and everyone gets the same treatment.
  • If something here is out of date or wrong, tell us and we'll fix it.

FAQ

A dialer, a CRM or agency management system, a quoting and enrollment platform, and member service after the sale, by people, voice AI, or both. Many telephonic agencies also use call tracking and consent certification for purchased leads.

Decide where the record lives, because the dialer, voice AI, and integrations all depend on it. Then fix your biggest leak: dialing and screening for cost per acquisition, or what happens after the sale for effectuation and retention.

Not between October 1 and December 7. Move in the spring or summer, and prove the new setup on one lead source or one group of members first. Check seat minimums and contract terms before you compare prices.

A few vendors sell to FMOs and carriers, though most voice AI is sold to the agency doing the calling. Medicare Vox, which began at Fair Square, is now owned by Senior Market Sales, part of Alliant. An FMO gets the most from it by offering it across its downline, like a quoting platform. Look for per-agency setup, consistent reporting across agencies, and connections to the tools your agencies already run.

Yes. Dialers, CRMs, and voice AI work the same way. Two things differ: the enrollment platform (on HealthCare.gov, many agents enroll through HealthSherpa) and the calendar. ACA open enrollment starts November 1 and overlaps most of Medicare's AEP, so ACA and Medicare agencies plan staffing differently.

Grow the book without growing the routine work with it. Put AI on the calls that don't need a license: screening, after-hours inbound, welcome calls, check-ins, and plan-change outreach. Keep licensed agents on the ones that do, and hire them to sell, not to dial and follow up. Then watch cost per acquisition by source, effectuation, and retention.

Advise on each member's whole picture, not one plan. CMS raised the cap on Medicare Advantage commissions for 2026, but some carriers now pay no commission on new enrollments in some plans. Pair the right Medicare plan with the dental, vision, hearing, or hospital indemnity coverage that fills its gaps. Add life or Supplement coverage where it fits, in separate conversations when the rules require it, and track ancillary attachment rate alongside retention.

Most dialers charge per seat, from about $50 to about $300 a seat a month, plus calling minutes. Rates depend on monthly or annual billing, some vendors set seat minimums, and a few price by platform tier or by quote. CRMs range from about $25 to $45 a month for one user to over $300 per user a month, billed annually, for enterprise platforms. Some quoting and CRM tools are free to agents contracted with the FMO that provides them. Voice AI is priced per minute, per call, per policy, as a flat monthly plan, or by quote.

Partly. Some bundle a dialer with a CRM, or a CRM with AI calling, but quoting and enrollment usually stays separate. Each guide notes what each platform bundles.

It can, because it includes both. It can also run alongside the tools you keep, connected through its integrations or a CSV import.

careCycle charges for the members on your book, not the seats on your floor: a rate per active policy, plus usage for calls and texts. There is no per-seat charge, every feature is included, and you can sign up to see your agency's plan in minutes.

Sources

Each guide carries its own sources, checked November 2026. Category prices on this page summarize them.

Start compounding your book.

Set up your agency

Running 50+ agents? Talk to us

Written by Vladimir Taikov, Head of Growth. Last checked .